The Legal Herald Logo
Legal Analysis By Attorneys
Breaking Legal News

New York, NY - 2 Shot at 230 Fifth Rooftop Bar Leaves 1 Dead and 1 Injured

Shooting at 230 Fifth Rooftop Bar
Published: August 10, 2020
By: Janean Cuffee
Last Updated on December 1, 2020

1 Woman Left Dead and 1 Man Injured in Shooting Outside 230 Fifth Rooftop Bar

According to NYPost, police responded to the calls and found a teenager from Connecticut dead and her boyfriend injured at 230 Fifth Rooftop Bar, located at 230 5th Ave, New York, NY 10001, on June 28th.

Erica Lopez, 19-years-old was killed, and her boyfriend Andres Arias, 21-years-old was injured. The two were celebrating at the venue and began talking to a group of six men and women. Lopez said one of the women groped her and her friend. When Arias confronted them, an argument arose. The shooting was a result of this minor bar dispute. After leaving the bar, the group followed them outside, where the suspect shot at them.

The suspect, Ruddy Osias 27-years-old, allegedly released about five shots aimed at Lopez, Arias, and their friends. Lopez pushed Arias out of the way resulting in him only being grazed, but she was fully hit. The two were taken to Bellevue Hospital, where Lopez passed away.

Osias is in police custody. He faces charges of second-degree murder and criminal possession of a weapon. He has no prior arrests but faces a life sentence.

laurence p banville esquire
Hi. My name is Laurence Banville.
I am licensed to practice law in New York and Washington, D.C. If you or a loved one needs legal assistance, I’d be happy to speak with you.
(888) 997-3792

Legal Options for Victims of a Shooting in a Bar

Attorney contributor Laurence Banville, an experienced violent crime lawyer, represents victims of violent crimes and their families in civil suits. In an interview, Laurence provided insight to help victims determine if they can sue for being shot at a bar

We asked what the legal responsibility of a bar owner is to uphold the safety of their customers. Laurence replied, “bar owners must ensure the safety of customers; it is a legal obligation. Bar owners must provide security to ensure the safety of their customers; for example, bars should have surveillance cameras, security guards, or other protective factors. 

Laurence said if property owners do not foster adequate security, they can be held negligent in a lawsuit. An example of negligence by a bar owner is if the crime was seen as foreseeable. A crime is reasonably foreseeable after a shooting if the property owner did not implement adequate security after knowing about previous criminal activity. 

Laurence highlighted the legal options of victims of violent crimes when we asked the steps victims should take. Laurence replied victims should first acquire the services of a crime victim attorney. A victim may have a case if their lawyer can prove the crime was foreseeable, as described above. In cases where violent crime may be considered predictable, the victim and their family may have a claim.

Got A Tip Or Questions 
About A Story?
Call Us!
The Legal Herald
About the Author
Janean Cuffee
About Janean Cuffee
Editor: Janean is an NYU Applied Psychology major with a double minor in history and sociology. As a NY native, she focuses on highlighting important legal news regarding violence, assaults, and social justice cases. Contact Janean: This article was fact checked prior to publishing by this author to ensure compliance with our rigorous editorial standards. We will only use authoritative sources. Our values compel us to provide only trustworthy information. If you find an error, please contact us.
Read some recent posts
Find A Local Lawyer

  • Details
  • Incident
Want To Contribute Breaking News? 
Contact Us Today
Legal Herald
10355 Kensington Shore Dr. #102
Orlando, FL 32827
Call: (888) 997-3792
© 2020 The Legal Herald, a division of Eagle Peak Marketing, LLC. All rights reserved.

We would like our readers to know that the information in this story may be sourced from secondary sources and may therefore contain inaccuracies. We will correct them if and when they are brought to our attention or we discover them through our editing process. If you have any concerns about this post, please contact us immediately and we will rectify issues. DISCLAIMER: The material contained in this post is for general informational purposes. It is not intended to constitute or express legal or medical advice. Any laws referenced herein are substantially based on general legal principles and may not be applicable to your particular situation. Laws can often be different from one jurisdiction to the next. The Legal Herald is not a law firm. Law firms and lawyers from around the country may apply to become a sponsor or contributor to The Legal Herald.
SitemapMedia RoomDisclaimer / Terms Of Service & Privacy Policy