Legal Analysis By Attorneys
Breaking Legal News
The Archdiocese of Chicago has announced the removal of Monsignor Daniel Mayall from ministry following allegations of sexual abuse involving a minor from approximately 30 years ago, reported CNA. Cardinal Blase Cupich detailed the decision in letters addressed to parishioners of Sts. Joseph and Francis Xavier Parish in Wilmette, Illinois, and St. Francis Borgia in Chicago.
The alleged incident is said to have occurred during Mayall’s tenure at St. Francis Borgia located at 8033 W Addison St, Chicago, IL 60634, where he served as pastor from 1993 to 2002. Mayall also held leadership roles at Sts. Joseph and Francis Xavier Parish from 2016 to 2021 and remained there in residence after retiring from full-time ministry in 2024, capping 44 years of service.
Cardinal Cupich emphasized adherence to the archdiocese’s child protection policies in his letters, stating that Mayall has been directed to step away from all ministry duties, including parish and school activities. While Mayall “strenuously denies this allegation,” he has agreed to comply with the directive, according to the cardinal.
The archdiocese has reported the allegation to civil authorities and extended support to the alleged victim through its victim ministry. A thorough investigation is now in the hands of law enforcement, after which the Archdiocesan Independent Review Board (IRB) will conduct its own review. Cardinal Cupich assured parishioners that no conclusions will be drawn until the investigative process is complete and recommendations are received from the IRB.
The allegations have brought a difficult moment for parishioners and the broader faith community. Cardinal Cupich expressed his commitment to fairness, stating, “Only by conducting a thorough and impartial review can we ensure fairness to all concerned.”
Monsignor Mayall’s removal marks a significant development as the Church continues to address allegations of past misconduct within its ranks. Further updates are expected as investigations proceed.
Survivors of Catholic priest sexual abuse often face long-lasting trauma and complex legal challenges when considering their options. To better understand the legal avenues available, attorney Erv Nevitt, a seasoned expert in handling sexual abuse cases, shares valuable information about the rights of survivors, the evolving statute of limitations, and the steps individuals can take to find accountability and support.
Darla Medina (Editor): Many parishioners are grappling with the recent allegations against Monsignor Daniel Mayall. What legal options exist for individuals who may have been sexually assaulted by a priest or clergy member, particularly when the alleged abuse happened decades ago?
Erv Nevitt (Attorney): Survivors of clergy abuse often face unique challenges, especially when significant time has passed. However, Illinois law provides some pathways. For example, the statute of limitations for filing a civil lawsuit has been expanded in recent years. This means that even if the abuse occurred decades ago, survivors may still be able to bring a case forward under certain circumstances.
Medina: What does the process look like for someone who decides to take legal action?
Nevitt: The first step is consulting an attorney experienced in sexual abuse cases. They can help determine whether the case falls within the statute of limitations. From there, survivors can pursue a civil suit against the individual perpetrator and potentially the institution that may have enabled or failed to prevent the abuse. Criminal charges are a separate matter and depend on law enforcement's investigation. It’s also important to note that many dioceses, including Chicago’s, have programs offering financial compensation or counseling support for survivors.
Medina: For survivors who may feel hesitant, what would you say to encourage them to come forward?
Nevitt: I understand the difficulty and fear associated with revisiting such trauma. But speaking out can be a step toward healing, accountability, and creating change. Survivors should know they are not alone and that there are legal and support systems designed to help them navigate this process.
If your child has been sexually abused by a priest, you don’t have to face this alone. Our experienced legal team is committed to advocating for survivors and their families, ensuring their voices are heard and justice is pursued. Contact us today for a free, confidential consultation to explore your options and begin the journey toward accountability and healing.
info@legalherald.com