The Legal Herald Logo
Legal Analysis By Attorneys
Breaking Legal News

Auburndale, FL - First Baptist Church of Auburndale Active Member Andrew "Drew" McGaffigan Faces 76 Charges of Child Pornography

Published: January 9, 2026
By: Darla Medina
Last Updated on January 9, 2026

Local Church Member Arrested on Multiple Child Pornography Charges

An active member of the First Baptist Church of Auburndale, located at 300 S Main St, Auburndale, FL 33823, faces serious legal trouble following his arrest on 76 counts of possessing child pornography. The Polk County Sheriff's Office reports that the arrest of 39-year-old Andrew "Drew" McGaffigan, stems from an investigation that began over a month ago, according to Fox 13.

Initial Arrest Leads to More Charges

McGaffigan was initially taken into custody on December 17 with 30 counts against him. However, a deeper examination of his electronic devices revealed an alarming number of additional illegal materials, prompting investigators to add 46 more charges. Detectives were alerted by the National Center for Missing and Endangered Children, which indicated that McGaffigan had been downloading explicit images of minors.

Disturbing Discoveries During Search

Following the execution of a search warrant, detectives uncovered 30 files depicting children subjected to sexual assault. Among the disturbing content found was a video in which a child was forced to engage in acts of bestiality. The files included victims as young as six months to 12 years old, raising significant concerns within the community.

Community Response and Ongoing Investigation

Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd expressed outrage over the situation, describing McGaffigan as "the worst of the worst." Notably, he emphasized the suspect's familial ties, stating, "Here is a married man with children of his own advocating for the sexual abuse of babies and children." McGaffigan's active role in his local church adds to the community's shock and concern.

As investigators continue to delve into McGaffigan's activities, they have yet to establish any connections between him and the identified victims. The sheriff's office is committed to conducting a thorough investigation, exploring whether McGaffigan may have abused children within his reach.

Michael Haggard Florida Lawyer
Hello, I’m attorney Michael Haggard. I am licensed to practice law in Florida. If you or a loved one needs legal assistance, I’d be happy to speak with you. Call me on the number below. It costs nothing, and it would be my honor to help you.
(888) 997-3792

Legal Options for Victims of Clergy Sexual Abuse

In the wake of alarming cases involving sexual abuse within church communities, many victims may wonder about their legal rights and options. To better understand the avenues available for those harmed by trusted figures, we spoke with Michael Haggard, an experienced lawyer specializing in sexual abuse cases. He offers valuable information on how victims can seek redress and the resources that are accessible to them.

Editor Darla Medina: With cases like this emerging, what legal options do victims have if they were abused by someone in a church setting?

Attorney Michael Haggard: Victims often have the right to file civil lawsuits against both the abuser and the church. Many times, institutions can be held accountable if they failed to protect children or if they knew about past incidents.

Medina: What challenges do these victims face in pursuing justice?

Haggard: One significant hurdle is often the stigma associated with coming forward. Victims may fear repercussions or mistrust from their community. Additionally, evidentiary hurdles can make cases complex.

Medina: Are there resources available for those looking to take legal action?

Haggard: Yes, many organizations and legal firms specialize in supporting survivors of abuse. Victims should seek legal counsel experienced in these types of cases to navigate the process effectively.

Your Voice Matters: Reach Out for Support

If you or a loved one has experienced abuse, remember that you are not alone. It’s important to seek guidance to navigate the legal complexities surrounding these cases. We encourage victims and their families to contact us for a free consultation. Together, we can ensure that your voice is heard and that steps are taken toward healing and justice. Don’t hesitate—reach out today.

Source

Fox 13

Got A Tip Or Questions 
About A Story?
Call Us!
The Legal Herald
888-997-3792
About the Author
Darla Medina
About Darla Medina
Editor: Darla is a content writer with a focus on the legal field. She covers cases of sexual abuse, drunk driving, and preventable violent crime for the Legal Herald. Contact Darla: darla@legalherald.com This article was fact checked prior to publishing by this author to ensure compliance with our rigorous editorial standards. We will only use authoritative sources. Our values compel us to provide only trustworthy information. If you find an error, please contact us.
Read some recent posts
Find A Local Lawyer
  • Details
  • Incident
Want To Contribute Breaking News? 
Contact Us Today
Legal Herald Logoinfo@legalherald.com
25 SE 2nd Ave Ste 550 #922
Miami, FL 33131
Call: (888) 997-3792
© 2025 The Legal Herald. All rights reserved.

We would like our readers to know that the information in this story may be sourced from secondary sources and may therefore contain inaccuracies. We will correct them if and when they are brought to our attention or we discover them through our editing process. If you have any concerns about this post, please contact us immediately and we will rectify issues. DISCLAIMER: The material contained in this post is for general informational purposes. It is not intended to constitute or express legal or medical advice. Any laws referenced herein are substantially based on general legal principles and may not be applicable to your particular situation. Laws can often be different from one jurisdiction to the next. The Legal Herald is not a law firm. Law firms and lawyers from around the country may apply to become a sponsor or contributor to The Legal Herald.
SitemapMedia RoomDisclaimer / Terms Of Service & Privacy Policy