Legal Analysis By Attorneys
Breaking Legal News
A local pastor has been charged with multiple felonies after police say he sexually abused a 14-year-old girl connected to his church, according to WTHR.
Marion County prosecutors have filed two counts of child molesting and two counts of confinement against Olman Amador, 40, who serves as a pastor at Iglesia Pentecostal Vida Y Esperanza. According to court records, Amador previously led Iglesia Pentecostal Divina Trinidad #5 located at 2142 N Mitthoefer Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46229, where prosecutors allege the abuse took place.
The Indiana Department of Child Services Central Intake Unit received a report on September 23, 2025, claiming that a 14-year-old girl had been sexually abused by Amador. Investigators say the pastor knew the victim through her family’s involvement with the church.
Court filings describe two separate instances of abuse. The first occurred three years ago when the teen was helping Amador at the church. The second reportedly happened earlier this year when Amador allegedly picked her up and drove her to a bus stop.
Amador denied all accusations when questioned by authorities. He reportedly told investigators, “Any teenager can say anything, but that doesn’t mean it is true.” He maintained he was never alone with the victim and never engaged in inappropriate contact.
Investigators interviewed a witness who said they saw the victim crying. When asked what was wrong, the teen allegedly confided what Amador had done. The witness and victim confronted Amador, who reportedly responded, “You do not have proof… only God, you, and I are the ones who saw.”
The court filing also states that the victim stayed silent for nearly two years—partly because Amador had asked for forgiveness, and partly because she cared for his children.
Authorities confirmed that Amador was booked into the Marion County Community Justice Campus. Iglesia Pentecostal Divina Trinidad #5 confirmed Amador’s former role as pastor but declined further comment.
When allegations of sexual abuse by a church pastor arise, the shock and heartbreak can leave families unsure of how to respond. To help explain the legal options available to victims and their loved ones, Jeff Gibson, an experienced Indiana sexual abuse lawyer, discusses how the law handles abuse cases involving clergy members.
Darla Medina (Editor): When cases like this arise involving allegations against a pastor, what legal options do families have in Indiana?
Jeff Gibson (Attorney): Families can take both criminal and civil actions. The criminal case is handled by the state, but victims and their families may also bring a civil lawsuit against the accused individual and potentially the church or organization if it failed to protect the victim.
Medina: Could a church be held responsible in such cases?
Gibson: Yes, if there’s evidence the church ignored complaints, failed to perform background checks, or allowed unsupervised contact with minors despite concerns. Institutions have a duty to safeguard those under their care.
Medina: For victims or their families, what steps should they take first?
Gibson: Reporting the abuse immediately is vital so investigators can act quickly. After that, speaking with an attorney experienced in sexual abuse cases can help families understand their rights, gather evidence, and take legal action when appropriate.
Victims of sexual abuse and their families should never face this battle alone. Legal help is available to protect your rights and seek accountability from those responsible. If you or someone you care about has been harmed by a pastor or other trusted figure, our team is here to listen and guide you through every step. Contact us today for a free, confidential consultation and take the first step toward healing and justice.
info@legalherald.com